Composite and Mixed Supply under GST
Introduction
The Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime in India classifies supplies of goods and services into different categories, including composite supply and mixed supply. These classifications are essential because they determine the applicable GST rates and treatment for bundled transactions. Understanding the difference between composite and mixed supplies is crucial for businesses to ensure correct tax compliance.
1. Composite Supply
Definition: Under Section 2(30) of the CGST Act, composite supply means a supply consisting of two or more taxable supplies of goods or services, or both, that are naturally bundled and supplied in conjunction with each other in the ordinary course of business. One of these supplies must be the principal supply.
Example:
- A hospital offers a package that includes surgery, diagnostic tests, and post-surgery care. In this case, the surgery is the principal supply, and the diagnostic tests and post-surgery care are ancillary to the surgery. The entire package is treated as a composite supply.
Tax Implication:
- In a composite supply, the entire transaction is taxed at the rate applicable to the principal supply. So, if the principal supply is exempt from GST, the whole composite supply will be exempt.
2. Mixed Supply
Definition: As per Section 2(74) of the CGST Act, mixed supply refers to a combination of two or more individual supplies of goods or services, or both, made together for a single price, which are not naturally bundled. Each of these supplies can be supplied separately and are not dependent on each other.
Example:
- A gift hamper containing chocolates, a watch, and a bottle of wine is a mixed supply. The items can be sold separately, and they are not naturally bundled.
Tax Implication:
- In the case of a mixed supply, the entire supply is taxed at the rate applicable to the highest rate among all the individual supplies in the bundle. For example, if the gift hamper contains a bottle of wine (taxed at 28%) and chocolates (taxed at 18%), the entire hamper will be taxed at 28%.
3. Key Differences Between Composite and Mixed Supply
Aspect | Composite Supply | Mixed Supply |
Bundling | Naturally bundled; occur together in business. | Artificial bundling; can be supplied independently. |
Principal Supply | Contains a principal supply. | No principal supply. All items are separate. |
Tax Rate | Taxed at the rate of the principal supply. | Taxed at the highest rate of any included item. |
Example | Transportation with insurance and loading services. | A combo of a watch, perfume, and chocolates. |
4. Practical Challenges
Identifying Composite and Mixed Supplies:
- One of the biggest challenges faced by businesses is the correct classification of supplies. While composite supplies are naturally bundled and expected to occur together, it might not always be clear-cut. Similarly, in mixed supplies, the combination of goods and services that don’t naturally belong together can complicate tax treatment.
Incorrect Classification:
- Misclassifying a supply as mixed or composite can lead to tax disputes, incorrect tax payment, and penalties. For example, classifying a composite supply as mixed could result in higher taxes being applied, whereas classifying mixed supplies as composite could lead to underpayment of GST.
5. Key Takeaways for Businesses
- Review Contracts: Always review the nature of your bundled offerings to ensure they are categorized correctly as either composite or mixed supply.
- Understand the Principal Supply: In composite supplies, identifying the principal supply helps in determining the correct GST rate. The principal supply is the main component to which the other supplies are ancillary.
- Tax Planning: Correct classification of supplies can lead to better tax planning and help avoid higher tax outgo in mixed supply situations.
- Consult Experts: In case of ambiguity, it is advisable to consult tax experts or seek advance rulings to avoid litigation or tax penalties.
Conclusion
The concept of composite and mixed supply under GST is crucial in determining the correct tax treatment for bundled goods and services. Businesses must carefully assess their offerings to ensure compliance with GST provisions. Understanding the difference between composite and mixed supplies will help businesses optimize their tax liabilities and avoid potential disputes with tax authorities.
Click here to send and enquiry to us